
Students will vote in the first thirty seconds. The useful part is the second round, when they have to name the fact that would change the vote. A vote that cannot name what would change it is just a louder opinion, and the room already has plenty of those.
Run it inside the course you are already teaching. The six variations below match Moneyling’s six core topics. You do not need a seventh unit called “decision lab” to do this on a Thursday.
Two rounds, any course
Round 1. Read the prompt for the course you are in. Students vote with a card: yes, no, or not yet. No speeches.
Round 2. Each student completes the response prompt: “I voted ___. The fact that would change my vote is ___. I would look for that fact in ___.” The blank at the end should be a document or a person, not “the internet.” Collect the slips. You can read three aloud without names.
Print the response prompt in 16-point type at the top of a half sheet. The rest of the sheet can stay blank. Students write more when the lines do not look like a test.
One variation for each core course
Earning. Prompt: “This job pays $2 more per hour and has no listed benefits. Take it?” The fact that changes a vote might be the schedule, the commute, or what “benefits” includes. Public sample, if you want a first click before you write your own prompt: the middle-school earning demo.
Saving. Prompt: “Move $15 from this paycheck to savings before you see the rest of the month. Do it?” A changing fact might be a bill due before the next check. Point adults-in-training at the biweekly bill calendar on the individuals blog if they want the grown-up version later.
Spending. Prompt: “The total is $64 and the cart has been open for three days. Buy it today?” A changing fact might be whether the $64 is this week’s groceries or a second version of something they own.
Investing. Prompt: “A friend says this account ‘is the investment.’ Agree to put in $20?” A changing fact is what the $20 would be invested in, and whether that money is needed soon. The public Investing course is the home for the full story. This vote is the warm-up, and it is not a recommendation.
Credit. Prompt: “Pay only the minimum this month so you can say yes to the trip. Do it?” A changing fact is the cost of carrying the rest, written as a number from a statement example you provide, fictional.
Managing risk. Prompt: “Skip the insurance this month because nothing bad happened last month. Do it?” A changing fact is the size of the bill if the thing you are insuring breaks, set next to the premium. Comfort and capacity, again, if you taught that lesson.